A faithful friend is a strong defense, and he that hath found him, hath found a treasure. — Ecclesiastics 6:14
The need to forgive is important. Jesus Christ died on the cross to forgive us of our sins. His example is the ultimate of love. We are expected to do the same and, as a result, we are forgiven. I have thought about what this means more than once, but today it seems to be something I need to write about.
My past as a college teacher spans nearly 40 years. Many times I’ve come into contact with others who wanted to talk. One such person said “I lost a dear friend and colleague to differences that separated us then and now.” Later, she said:
It was painful then and less so now, but the feelings toward this person remain with me. I can’t say that all of the issues between us were created by this person (another female colleague). In my heart, I feel they were. The things that were done hurt me and my family. To this day I still don’t understand why it all happened. I know that I miss her, yet I really don’t know her anymore. She has never written to me or talked to me (now 15+ years) nor have I tried to contact her. Strange as it sounds, she might not even realize what she did to our friendship. And yet, I must believe that she does. I also believe she has no motivation to speak to me or to apologize for her behavior. We are now as though we never knew each other, and I find that sad and disappointing. More than once I’ve wanted to talk to her. Not knowing what she thinks keeps me from doing so. Also, I don’t because I know in my heart she destroyed our relationship. I still think about it from time to time, and I still wish for what we had – a special friendship!
And so, that is where I am with this introduction. If she doesn’t speak out and forgive her colleague or apologize for her behavior as well, I’m afraid they will never be friends again. As it stands, that is the case today. This raises two questions:
- Should she say something?
- Should she bury the emotions?
If she were to say something, it might be the first step to opening communication between them. Having said that, as it turns out, the person to whom I’m speaking about is not the kind of person who asks forgiveness very easily. After all, from her point of view, why does she need forgiveness when her friend is the one who destroyed their personal and professional relationship? Maybe it would be easier if she were more inclined to be forgiving. The fact is there are people who are inclined to ask forgiveness and there are people who are less inclined to ask forgiveness. At times I think the latter group overdoes it. This causes me to wonder if those who are ready to forgive at the drop of a hat really mean it.
Also, I must point out that I’m not convinced that she is ready to forgive her colleague from years past. In some sense, it is too easy to write a letter, pick up the phone, or email her. As I understand it, her behavior for the better part of 6 years while at another job with this lady was pure hell and, therefore, for her husband and children, too. It was so bad that on occasion she referred to her as an “evil” person.
I wonder if it is true that evil people live among us. I know that she thinks so while wishing it otherwise. And, now, at this very moment, the first real opportunity to talk about what had happened between the two of them, she feels somewhat foolish (like a cry baby, if you will).
Grow up “Sherry” (not her real name), she catches herself saying. “Grow up. This is stupid. Get over it.” Well, in many ways, I believe she is over it. She is human though, and she does have the right to try and understand life and, where possible, learn from her experiences. And, part of what I’ve learned over the years is that it is okay to sit, listen, and share thoughts with another person who feels comfortable enough to do so.
Should she forgive this person or not is the question? And, if she does, what does it mean to her and the events that transpired years earlier? Answers to these questions aren’t easy, but there are smart people with excellent ideas to consider. Take, for example, the article “When to Forgive” by the American theologian – Avery Dulles [1].
In short, Dulles says that forgiveness is not automatic. He argues “…that the person receiving it be sorry for any wrong committed….” His comment speaks to the heart of the matter. She has no way of knowing that her friend is sorry. Also, she has no tolerance for being caught a fool a second time. What if the person repeated the evil actions again? Frankly, I’m not sure what Sherry or her family would do this time around. So, you can see if she were to extend forgiveness without knowing the heart of the other person, then more harm may result to everyone. I don’t think she could deal with that very well.
Similarly, as pointed out by Steven Payne [2] in “Apology Accepted,” for the battered wife to apologize to other husband for burning supper may be viewed as “enabling her abuser.” Being an enabler is not the right way to regain or maintain a friendship. So, should she forgive this person but not apologize to her and, if so, what does that mean as a Christian (which she is)? Or, perhaps stated somewhat differently, should she forgive her or should she wait for the apology from this person and, if so, how long?
Ideally, an apology would lay the foundation for a hopeful coming together. But, what if she apologized but didn’t want anything to do with Sherry? Does she want an apology, or does she want the old friendship, or both? Also, what if this other person said “I’m sorry” but, then, she turned and walked away? She may have acknowledged her responsibility in humiliating and shaming Sherry by taking responsibility for what she did, but have no interest in associating with her.
As you can see, there is more than one possible outcome. That is life. It is exciting, interesting, and complex.
Betrayer is a serious matter. Sherry feels betrayed, and she is living it (i.e., when she allows herself to touch the moments of yesterday). What happened to her is a betrayer of friendship that hurts to the core. Whether Sherry can live with her feelings is up to her. Waiting for an apology is not the right course of action though. Maybe what ought to be done is this: What if Sherry wrote her friend and said her piece, realizing that (being human) her involvement, however unknown to her may have contributed to the failed friendship.
In other words, it takes a big person to forgive the other person through an apology when that person feels it isn’t her fault. It may not straighten anything out except the feeling that “now it is in the past, all of it.” Being Christian, after all, is about forgiveness. And, it is central to putting the past behind you so that you can live comfortably in the present. Who knows, Sherry’s friend may get it or she may not until much later or, perhaps, never. One thing is for sure, not stepping up to the plate to promote reconciliation means the door is likely to be closed and the past will continue to inflict its unresolved issues on the future. So, why not “Just do it” or as Payne [2] said in his article:
“…go ahead and take a chance. Try apologizing, as Jesus says, to the brother or sister, husband or wife, parent or child, teach or student, boss or employee, friend or stranger, who may have anything against you.” – Mt 5:23
References
- Dulles, A. (2002). When to Forgive. America. 187:7. p. 8.
- Payne, S. (2007). Apology Accepted. Spiritual Life: A Journal of Contemporary Spirituality. 53:1:23-34.